They Understand Your Feelings…But Do They Care? Understanding the Psychology of Empathy when Treating Narcissism

Empathy is often described as the ability to understand another person’s feelings, but the psychological picture is more nuanced. Understanding empathy in narcissism requires distinguishing between recognizing another person’s emotions and genuinely caring about their experience. Empathy involves understanding another person’s emotions, resonating with their experience, and genuinely caring about their inner world. These are related capacities, but they are not necessarily the same thing.

This distinction becomes particularly important when treating narcissism. Many people with narcissistic characteristics can recognize another person’s emotional experience. The greater difficulty may be sustaining recognition of the other person as a separate person when that experience becomes threatening, frustrating, shaming, or injurious to their sense of self. The question is not always whether empathy exists, but whether a person can maintain access to it when it becomes emotionally difficult.

To explore this topic in further detail, listen to the full podcast episode of the Narcissism Decoder HERE.

Empathy in narcissism and the difference between understanding and caring

Empathy in Narcissism: Why Can It Become Difficult?

Empathy is one of those terms we hear all the time, but it actually refers to several different psychological capacities. At its core, empathy involves understanding another person’s thoughts, feelings, and perspective; emotionally resonating with their experience; and responding with genuine concern for what they are experiencing. These are often described as cognitive empathy, affective or emotional empathy, and compassionate empathy or empathic concern (1).

These capacities can overlap, but they are not necessarily the same thing. A person may be remarkably good at recognizing what another person is feeling without having the capacity to respond with genuine concern. Being able to understand another person’s emotional world does not tell us what someone does with that understanding.

How Can You Tell If Someone Has Empathy?

A prototypical example may look something like this. A patient comes into my office emotionally devastated after ending his relationship with his girlfriend. She responds by accusing him of being cold, distant, selfish, and narcissistic. He knows that she was hurt, but he also felt that ending the relationship was something he needed to do. Now he is beginning to question himself: “Was this a selfish thing to do? Maybe I really don’t have empathy.”

Rather than immediately accepting either his girlfriend’s accusation or his own conclusion, we would want to become curious. What actually happened? Why did he decide to end the relationship? How did he communicate that decision? What did he understand about what she was feeling? And what was happening inside of him as he watched her become hurt and angry?

We have to look more closely at his capacity to recognize her experience while also maintaining contact with his own:

  • Did he dismiss her feelings, belittle her, or walk away without explanation?
  • Or, did he recognize that she was hurting, acknowledge the significance of the relationship, make space for her emotions, and still decide that the relationship needed to end?

Because she was deeply hurt by his decision does not, by itself, tell us whether he acted without empathy. We need to understand the process that led to the behavior, not simply the outcome.

Recognizing empathy and emotional understanding in relationships

What Is the Difference Between Understanding and Caring?

The boyfriend could have deeply understood that she was going to be hurt and still believed that ending the relationship was the right thing to do. Empathy does not mean preventing someone from experiencing disappointment, frustration, or loss. It does not mean sacrificing our own needs to protect someone else from painful feelings.

He may have understood that she would feel rejected, abandoned, angry, or heartbroken. He may even have been able to anticipate how she was likely to respond. But knowing what she is feeling is not the same thing as caring about what she is feeling. And caring about what she is feeling is not the same thing as agreeing with her or giving her what she wants.

In healthy relating, “I understand your experience” is accompanied by an ongoing recognition that your mind matters independently of mine. You remain a separate person in my mind, with feelings and needs that are real—even when they are different from my own.

Why Can Empathy Become Difficult in Narcissistic Relating?

This distinction becomes particularly important when talking about narcissism. A person can make a decision that is painful to someone else without necessarily losing sight of that person’s subjectivity. The more important question is whether they can continue to recognize the other person’s feelings as real and meaningful when those feelings become difficult to tolerate.

Think again about the breakup. Perhaps the girlfriend becomes extremely angry, tells him that he has destroyed her life, and calls him selfish, cold, and narcissistic. What happens to his capacity to recognize her experience when he is the target of her anger?

Does he:

  • Withdraw
  • Become defensive
  • Change the subject
  • Explain why she is wrong to feel the way she does

His ability to understand her experience may not have disappeared altogether. What may become difficult is continuing to hold her experience in mind when doing so requires him to tolerate his own painful feelings. 

What Does Empathy Look Like in a Relationship?

A person can become extraordinarily skilled at reading other people’s emotions without necessarily developing the capacity to maintain an enduring sense of the other person as someone whose inner life matters independently of their own. In psychodynamic terms, this gets us closer to the question of object love.

Can I maintain an emotional investment in you as a separate person—even when you frustrate me, disappoint me, criticize me, or fail to provide what I need? That is a much more complicated question than simply asking, “Does this person have empathy?”

Empathy in narcissism and maintaining emotional connection

Conclusion

Empathy is not simply an all-or-nothing quality. A person may understand another person’s emotional experience, emotionally resonate with it, or recognize their pain while having difficulty sustaining genuine concern under emotional pressure. Looking at the process rather than simply the outcome gives us a more nuanced way of understanding empathy, particularly in narcissistic relating.

The encouraging part is that this gives us more to work with. Instead of reducing someone to “un-empathetic” or “lacking empathy,” we can become curious about what happens when another person’s feelings challenge the self and whether the person can continue to recognize that person as separate and meaningful. That deeper understanding creates an opportunity for more integrated and meaningful relating.

If you found this discussion helpful, be sure to stay tuned for the next article, where we’ll explore the more complicated side of empathy and answer the question: what is a dark empath? We’ll look at how understanding another person’s emotions can become a tool for control or manipulation, and how to recognize the difference between genuine empathy and an empathic presentation.

Dr. Anthony Mazzella is a psychoanalyst and psychodynamic psychotherapist specializing in the treatment of narcissism and personality disorders.

Continue The Journey

If you or your loved one is in need of support, contact us today and take the first step toward understanding, growth, and emotional balance.

For further insights and support, explore:

The Narcissism Decoder Podcast: get a deeper understanding through expert discussions and real-life stories.

These resources can provide additional guidance as you navigate your journey toward healing and personal growth.

(1): Riess, Helen. “The Science of Empathy.” Journal of Patient Experience vol. 4,2 (2017): 74-77. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5513638/. 

Don’t Hesitate To Contact Dr. Mazzella

Have a question? Get in touch now!

Call me:

Book Telehealth Visit

I regret to inform you that I do not accept insurance and I am not participating with any insurance companies at this time. Payment for services rendered will be the responsibility of the patient directly. I apologize for any inconvenience this may cause. More information about financing can be found on this page.

*All indicated fields must be completed.
Please include non-medical questions and correspondence only.

Accessibility Toolbar

Scroll to Top